I found the chest! (I didn't end up taking the loot though) It took like 3 hours mainly because this was a random location that no one knew where it was (as opposed to the snowball arena from the last hunt), on top of the fact that I didn't initially know where to begin to find the chest. When you said the screenshot was taken from the location of the chest, that helped a lot since I already found the location but just didn't have any clue of what to do. I opened it up, but there was only the 16 granite blocks and the armor stand you said ): I feel like I could have just walked outside my town to the newly generated terrain, grabbed the granite, and crafted the armor stand with a few sticks all in under 5 minutes without even going on the expedition haha...
I really liked how much more time it took to find it because of the completely unknown location perhaps no one might have set foot on before, and at the same time would love to open the chest up knowing that hours of scavengering are about to pay off. I think on the last one, I might have gotten a little lucky finding it super fast, but the reward was a tad too much, but this one was a more difficult one with very little. The unobtainable items in and of themselves are a priceless reward, and was a huge encouragement to the treasure hunt.
On another note, I enjoy your riddles! They challenge me to think of how your vagueness is hinting me at something.
August 2014 Hidden Chest wrote:
Ride South.
Count down: three, two...
Come out on top,
Continue on your journey.
You have won.
This one made me think a little bit before going, and at one point I had run on top of the rails in the direction of the chest, but stopped probably about 50 blocks before seeing it, and turned around unfortunately haha. Abrum and I ended up spending an hour looking for the chest in other places near the rail where we thought it was around.
August 2014 Hidden Chest #2 wrote:
Go to the land surrounded by the shades of the setting sun and the midday sky. Up in a tree will you find your treasure.
This one, Abrum and I spent maybe a good couple to 3 hours looking, but in the wrong places because we thought the riddle meant one thing, but it was a little bit different. We ended up going to the mesa biome because that is the land of the sunset's colors, and searching all of the trees. This is probably my favorite riddle you've done, and I love ones like this! We didn't get the reward, but it was a good attempt
Very clever how the interpretation was to be taken as a land with the mesa surrounding it, but not necessarily in the mesa, along with the fact that the shades of the daytime sky was additionally painting a picture of a river that I didn't pick up on.
September 2014 Hidden Chest wrote:
Explore the caves, descend the canyon.
Again, while this took me probably shorter than it should have on average between half an hour to an hour for the entire journey, the riddle was unique with descending the canyon. The screenshot was of a very well-known landmark though, which made it much, much easier to just go straight to, and then follow the riddle as opposed to having to hunt down the location that I've never seen before and have to deduct clues from the screenshot to go find the location. i.e. it's snowy and has trees-- which is still pretty vague, which is a good thing! Having to hunt down the riddle/screenie location seems to be a good factor that takes time to do.
All in all, the riddles and adventures are great! Ones of about this difficulty with just a screenshot, or ones like the "land surrounded by the shades of the setting sun" with just the riddle that tell just barely enough info to make you take a while to think and/or search, are really awesome. I'd love to see rare items or unobtainables in the future similar to the last one!
Perhaps an additional complication could be that even if you find the location via vague a screenshot or riddle, is that the chest is relatively nearby, but another riddle/hint makes it such that you have to look around and think about what to do based on it. Or even leave some small hints around the area so that when the person arrives, they'll pick up on a couple suspicious things, and follow them to where they think the hint is trying to lead them. With this hunt, I found a spiral staircase nearby that lead up to one of the hill plateaus and thought to myself-- "hmmm, comic might be leading me somewhere with this staircase". It ended up shifting my search radius over to a different location, but of course it was misleading possibly because someone else dug it long ago... maybe months. With this additional factor, it would be possible to put the chest even 200 blocks away from a screenshot location, but a subtle hint in the terrain every 50-100 blocks that raises an eyebrow and encourages the adventurer to keep going in that direction and shift their search region over everytime they find a new hint.